Before you go!

Sign up for the FREE weekly email newsletter from the publishers of American Nurse Today. You’ll get breaking news features, exclusive investigative stories, and more — delivered to your inbox.

Sign up today!

*By submitting your e-mail, you are opting in to receiving information from Healthcom Media and Affiliates. The details, including your email address/mobile number, may be used to keep you informed about future products and services.
November 28, 2018

By: Lillee Gelinas, MSN, RN, CPPS, FAAN

You want to refuse a flu shot? Welcome to the epidemic!

I cradled a very sick child with the flu in my arms this week and asked why the mother had insisted on her child NOT being vaccinated with the flu vaccine a month earlier. “It’s my right,” the mother replied.

The Texas (where I live) Department of State Health Services reported nearly 10,000 flu and pneumonia-related deaths duringthe last flu season.This is a spike of nearly 27% above of the previous year. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) reports that 80% of the children who died nationally were unimmunized or under-immunized. Since the flu season in Texas peaks between December through February, those of us in the caring professions are getting ready for the onslaught. How many more deaths do we need in 2019? Does this mother really realize the danger confronting her child?

I am getting tired of the lame tactics, rhetoric and politics aimed at swaying public opinion on the dangers of vaccines, while the innocent get infected and needlessly die from preventable illnesses, like the flu. Although the CDC reports low flu activity so far, the first pediatric death occurred this week. In Texas, the “opt-out” of vaccine policy is hurting all of us. It’s time to change that stance.

Why do we debate the issue of getting flu shots? Are we all scientists who can intelligently counter the current evidence base about the importance of community immunity? Does the opinion of the few outweigh the science base of the best researchers on the planet?

About 40% of the children in the State of Texas have parents who opt out of vaccine administration of any kind, yet they are permitted to attend school. The Texas Administrative Code (TAC) §97.62 describes conditions under which individuals can seek exemptions from Texas immunization requirements. The policy provides for exclusions from compliance based on medical contraindications, active duty with the armed forces of the United States, and reasons of conscience, including a religious belief.

As a nurse and a military veteran, I am trying to understand the debate. The exclusions as written seem reasonable. But taken to the extreme as in the current situation appears archaic. Opt out of immunizing your children? Why? Is the opinion base stronger than the evidence base? We need to see vaccination as a civic duty as well as an individual mandate to try to stay healthy. It’s all based on the concept of “herd immunity”, which I had never “heard” of until I studied the concept of immunity as a nursing student.

Herd immunity is based on the public health concept that the more people who are protected, the less likely the virus will spread and the fewer people will get sick and eventually die from the disease. We’ve now broken the track record on the value of flu vaccination and the concept of herd immunity because of the number of people who can opt out, at least in the State of Texas.

The reality is that flu comes every year. We can’t stop it. Either we are prepared or we’re not. But the new “anti-vaccer’s” voices, the group of vaccine protestors who say no to vaccines, are making their statements heard.

It’s time we put public policy and science ahead of rhetoric and opinion. The State of Texas needs to overturn the current vaccine opt-out stance for all vaccines, not just the flu vaccine, and legislate that to protect the public, all children must present documentation of current immunization status prior to being admitted to school.

How bad will the next flu season be? I don’t know. Neither do you.

I do know that I don’t want one more child compromised by the flu, or measles, or any other preventative disease. The power of positive change, the power to save lives, and the power to change vaccination policies is in our hands. Let’s get on with it and let science be our guide. Let’s step up and change the current state policy. Our children deserve nothing less.


Lillee Gelinas is editor-in-chief for American Nurse Today.

Selected references

Ackerman T. Flu killed nearly 10,000 Texans in 2017-2018. San Antonio Express News.June 27, 2017. expressnews.com/news/local/article/Flu-killed-nearly-10-000-Texans-in-2017-2018-13028706.php

American Nurses Association. Position Statement on Immunizations. 2015. nursingworld.org/practice-policy/nursing-excellence/official-position-statements/id/immunizations/

Garten R, Blanton L, Elal AIA, et al. Update: Influenza activity in the United States during the 2017-18 season and composition of the 2018-19 influenza vaccine. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2018;67(22):634-42.

Texas Department of State Health Services. Exemption information—School immunizations. January 8, 2018. dshs.texas.gov/immunize/school/exemptions.aspx

4 thoughts on “You want to refuse a flu shot? Welcome to the epidemic!”

  1. DeLora says:

    The statistical information provided in this article “…reported nearly 10,000 flu and pneumonia-related deaths during the last flu season” is a newspaper reference? Texas Department of State Health Services seems to give by far, way less numbers.

  2. Debi Blank, RN says:

    I live & practice school nursing in a state that allows parents to “opt out” of vaccinations for most of the same reasons as Texas; medical, philosophical and religious. In order to cut down on the numbers of “convenience” exemptions, parents are required to submit exemption statements every year. The same is true for medical exemptions, the thought here is that medical conditions change. In our state the flu vaccine is not required. Recently vaccines were added to the mandatory list for students entering 7th & 11th grades and its been a bear getting parents to take the rule seriously. Over the course of 37 years in the trenches I’ve probably heard almost every reason not to vaccinate a child from vaccines causing Autism to “I think its cruel to stick pins in little children.” Neither of which bear up under scientific scrutinity. The Autism connection is unproven and being old enough to have had some of those “Childhood diseases,” I wish my parents had the opportunity to have been so cruel as to stick pins in me. And I never had the really devastating diseases or life-long effects that accompanied many of these diseases.

  3. Tali says:

    Tambra, you have no scientific basis for your comments and opinion. You are just regurgitating things you have read on Facebook. I’m sure your “other prevention methods” are essential oils and voodoo curses. I really hope you aren’t a practicing nurse.

  4. Tambra says:

    If your child is vaccinated and gets near an unvaccinated child with the flu, your kid’s ‘supposedly protected’. Also, the flu shot did little to ward off the flu from vaccinated kids last year, and there are dangers from the flu shot, so needlessly exposing them to it is NOT a good option when washing hands, taking vitamin C and other prevention methods work about the same, worh NO side affects.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


By submitting this form, you agree to our comment policy.

Test Your Nursing Knowledge

Answer this interactive quiz to be entered to win a gift card.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Insights Blog

Today’s News in Nursing