Patient Safety / Quality

Color awareness: A must for patient assessment

Your 75-year-old patient is short of breath. Knowing his natural skin tone is dark, you’re unsure how to assess for central cyanosis.

An adolescent patient has a serious soft-tissue injury of the leg, but you can’t see bruising because her skin is darkly tanned.

After a sexual assault, a dark-skinned patient arrives at the emergency department with a suspected abrasion of the labia minor. But even when you apply contrast medium, the injury is hard to detect because of the surrounding skin color.

The skin is the body’s largest organ. Skin color can reflect a patient’s overall health and is an important part of assessing skin breakdown and wound healing. For instance:

  • pallor may indicate anemia
  • cyanosis may signal hypoxemia
  • the degree and extent of skin redness is important in burn care
  • understanding skin-color changes is crucial for detecting and staging pressure ulcers.

But the exact nature of such color changes as pallor, cyanosis, and redness varies with the patient’s natural skin color—and this can pose a challenge in providing clinically competent and culturally sensitive care. Long a source of discrimination, skin color is a socially sensitive issue. Identifying and evaluating skin color raises questions about stereotyping and the social benefits of being “color-blind.”

Most skin-care guidelines apply mainly to patients with light skin. Yet the Hispanic and Asian populations of the United States are expected to triple over the next half-century. By 2050, people of Hispanic, African, Asian, and Caribbean ancestry likely will represent more than half the total U.S. population. Obviously, healthcare professionals will be caring for an increasingly diverse population of many ethnic backgrounds and skin colors. This article explores the concept of skin-color awareness, discusses the role of skin color in nursing assessment, and explains why healthcare providers should practice color awareness, not blindness.


Constitutive vs. facultative skin color

Constitutive skin color is the natural, genetically determined color of the epidermis, uninfluenced by ultraviolet (UV) light or hormone exposure. Typically, it’s seen in areas of little or no sun exposure, such as the underside of the upper arm.

In contrast, facultative skin color results from exposure to UV light and other environmental factors. Tanning, for instance, changes the composition of melanin in the skin and increases the amount and size of melanin produced by melanocytes. Thus, facultative skin is darker than constitutive skin. (See the box below.)

How skin gets its color

Melanocytes are cells in the epidermis (the skin’s outer layer) that are genetically programmed to produce a specific amount of melanin—the pigment that gives skin its specific color. Skin color is the result of reflected and absorbed light from unpigmented skin, mixed with colors of various constitutive pigments, such as melanins, hemoglobins, and carotenes. As light hits the skin’s surface, it is either reflected diffusely back, scattered, or absorbed by particles within the skin. The most superficial layer of the epidermis transmits most light through to the more basal layers of the epidermis, dermis, and hypodermis. These layers scatter some light while melanin in the epidermis absorbs light, producing an orange, brown, or black color.

In the dermis, some light is scattered and some is absorbed by collagen, yielding a yellowish color. In both the epidermis and dermis, carotene absorbs light, also creating a yellow hue. Hemoglobin in the superficial capillaries absorbs some light; oxygenated hemoglobin produces a reddish tint while reduced hemoglobin yields a bluish color. Finally, the subcutaneous fat layer in the hypodermis scatters back a large portion of light that has made it through all the layers.

Why color “blindness” can reduce health outcomes

Skin color may be a source of disparate health outcomes for many reasons, not just discrimination or poor access to care. Disparity can occur if well-intentioned healthcare professionals are color “blind”—disregarding a patient’s skin color because they believe doing this will help them provide the same level of care to all patients regardless of skin color. But this approach limits the relevance of skin color to health and limits nurses’ ability to provide individualized care.

For instance, as a nurse you’ve been trained to assess skin breakdown by testing the skin’s blanch response to light finger pressure. When evaluating for a stage I pressure ulcer, you apply light pressure to the skin; this temporarily squeezes blood out of the underlying area, reducing local blood volume and causing an area of blanching, or whitening. If the skin appears red, blue, or purplish and doesn’t blanch, you might classify the area as a stage I pressure ulcer. But in dark-skinned patients, the blanching test has limited value. The greater amounts of melanin in dark skin may mask the blanch response, making the color change invisible despite the local change in blood volume.

Forensic implications

What’s more, researchers studying forensic sexual assault examinations found data suggesting black women had a lower prevalence of genital injury after rape than white women. They suggested that the difference in reported injury prevalence wasn’t related to race or ethnicity but to either reduced visibility of injury in dark-skinned women (compared to light-skinned women) or actual differences in skin properties, depending on skin color. They also found dark-skinned women had fewer injuries than light-skinned women after consensual sexual intercourse. Their research showed that skin color more fully explained the differences in the numbers of genital injuries than race or ethnicity in both groups of women—those who’d been raped and those who’d had consensual intercourse. In other words, the prevalence of genital injuries in dark-skinned women has likely been underreported because of difficulty seeing the injuries.

These findings are particularly important given the role of forensic evidence in the criminal justice system. Women whose injuries are documented during the forensic examination have better judicial outcomes at every step of criminal justice proceedings than women without documented injuries. Those with documented injuries are more likely to report rape to the police, more likely to file charges, more likely to have their cases prosecuted, and more likely to have the accused persons convicted.

Cultivating color awareness

Unlike color “blindness,” color awareness acknowledges that skin color is relevant to health and shouldn’t be ignored. What’s more, it acknowledges that people across the skin-color continuum may not want to be treated as raceless, colorless, or without ethnicity, since much of a person’s identity stems from being a specific color. By applying color awareness to health assessment, healthcare professionals can more appropriately manage skin conditions among patients of all skin colors and help reduce disparities in healthcare delivery.

Skin color assessment methods

The most common way to assess skin color is to use the Fitzpatrick scale, which was developed to classify skin type during a study of UV dosing in psoriasis treatment. (See the box below.) The latest version of this scale classifies skin into one of six types based on its reaction to sun exposure. However, this scale isn’t particularly helpful in nursing assessment because of its focus on the effects of sun exposure and because dark-skinned people fall into primarily one category.

Other assessment scales use different classification criteria. One scale classifies skin color as dark, darkish, or fair. A second scale uses four categories—fair, fair/medium, medium, and dark. A third uses a skin-tone chart consisting of eight categories of color ranging from 1 (lightest) to 8 (darkest).

Skin color also can be assessed through digital image analysis or measured with such instruments as a spectrophotometer or colorimeter. These techniques generally are used in research, to collect forensic evidence, or during dermatologic procedures. For clinical skin-color assessment, visual inspection and asking patients about their normal skin color are the best methods.

Recommendations for assessing dark-skinned patients

When assessing a patient’s skin, use natural light or a halogen lamp rather than fluorescent light, which may alter the skin’s true color and give the illusion of a bluish tint.

Skin color is particularly important in detecting cyanosis and staging pressure ulcers. Cyanosis occurs when a person has 5 g/dL of unoxygenated hemoglobin in the arterial blood. Central cyanosis (cyanosis of the lips, mucous membranes, and tongue) occurs when arterial oxygen saturation falls below 85% in patients with normal hemoglobin levels. In light-skinned patients, cyanosis presents as a dark bluish tint to the skin and mucous membranes (which reflects the bluish tint of unoxygenated hemoglobin). But in dark-skinned patients, cyanosis may present as gray or whitish (not bluish) skin around the mouth, and the conjunctivae may appear gray or bluish. In patients with yellowish skin, cyanosis may cause a grayish-greenish skin tone.

Checking for pressure ulcers

When checking for pressure ulcers in dark-skinned patients, remember that dark skin rarely shows the blanch response. Instead, after applying light pressure, look for an area that’s darker than the surrounding skin or that’s taut, shiny, or indurated (hardened). If you suspect a skin area is becoming damaged, use the light from a camera flash system to enhance your visualization of dark skin; with the patient’s permission, take a series of digital images each day to document changes in wound color, size, and depth. Check for localized changes in skin texture and temperature. Early signs of skin damage include induration, bogginess (less-than-normal stiffness), and increased warmth at the injury site compared to nearby areas. Over time, as tissues become more damaged, the area becomes cooler to the touch.

Erythema also may be hard to detect in dark-skinned patients. In a light-skinned patient, irritation may cause redness. But in a dark-skinned person, it may cause hyperpigmentation (increased pigmentation) or hypopigmentation (reduced pigmentation), with no redness visible. Sometimes, dark skin takes on a dark bluish-purple tint at the site of early pressure-ulcer development. So when caring for a dark-skinned patient at risk for pressure ulcers, keep in mind that assessing by touch is as important as visual inspection. (See the box below for more assessment tips).

To provide high-quality care for dark-skinned patients, healthcare professionals shouldn’t use skin assessment standards based on light skin color. We must increase the body of knowledge pertaining to appropriate methods for assessing skin colors along the entire continuum. Until all healthcare disciplines practice color awareness, we may be promoting healthcare disparities based on skin color. We can’t afford to be “color-blind.”

Selected references

Choe YB, Jang SJ, Jo SJ, Ahn KJ, Youn JI. The difference between the constitutive and facultative skin color does not reflect skin phototype in Asian skin. Skin Res Technol. 2006;12:68-72. doi:10.1111/j.0909-725X.2006.00167.x.

deRigal J, Mazis ID, Diridollou S, et al. The effect of age on skin color and color heterogeneity in four ethnic groups. Skin Res Technol. 2010;16:168-178. doi:10.1111/j.1600-0846.2009.00416.x.

Sachdeva, S. Fitzpatrick skin typing: applications in dermatology. Indian J Dermalot Venereol Leprol. 2009;75:93-96. doi:10.4103/0378-6323.45238.

Sommers MS, Zink T, Baker RB, et al. The effects of age and ethnicity on physical injury from rape. JOGNN. 2006;35(2):199-207. doi:10.1111/J.1552-6909.2006.00026.x.

Sommers MS, Zink TM, Fargo JD, et al. Forensic sexual assault examination and genital injury: is skin color a source of health disparity? Am J Emerg Med. 2008;26:857-866. doi:10.1016/j.ajem.2007.11.025.

Yamaguchi Y, Brenner M, Hearing V. The regulation of skin pigmentation. J Biol Chem. 2007;282:27557-27561. doi:10.1074/jbc.R700026200.

Marilyn S. Sommers is the Lillian Brunner Professor of Medical-Surgical Nursing at the University of Pennsylvania School of Nursing in Philadelphia.

Related Articles:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 

Shares